Kylebooker VTG Smith & Hawken Cabin Hunting Plaid Wool Button Vest – Men’s Size XL USA: A Review on Value for Money
As an avid fishing enthusiast, I understand the importance of having the right gear—not just for performance but also for comfort and durability. Recently, I came across the Kylebooker VTG Smith & Hawken Cabin Hunting Plaid Wool Button Vest in Men’s Size XL (USA sizing) and decided to evaluate its value for money. This vest is marketed as a vintage-style hunting and outdoor piece, but its functionality extends well into fishing and general outdoor activities. Below, I’ll break down its features, quality, and overall cost-effectiveness to determine whether it’s a worthwhile investment.
1. Material & Durability
The first thing that stands out about this vest is its 100% wool construction. Wool is an excellent material for outdoor wear because it provides natural insulation, moisture-wicking properties, and breathability. Unlike synthetic fabrics, wool retains warmth even when wet—a crucial feature for early morning fishing trips or chilly hunting excursions.
The VTG (vintage) tag suggests that this vest is either a well-preserved older model or a reproduction designed to mimic classic styles. Either way, the stitching appears robust, and the wool feels thick and tightly woven, indicating good durability. For anglers who spend long hours outdoors, this vest should hold up well against wear and tear.
2. Design & Functionality
The plaid pattern gives it a rugged, outdoorsy aesthetic, making it suitable for both hunting and casual wear. The button-front closure is simple yet effective, allowing for easy layering over a shirt or under a jacket.
One of the key aspects I look for in fishing vests is pocket utility. While this vest isn’t specifically designed for fishing, it does feature two large front pockets, which are useful for storing small tackle boxes, bait, or even a compact fishing reel. However, dedicated fishing vests usually have more specialized compartments, so this may not be ideal for those who need extensive storage.
3. Comfort & Fit
The Men’s Size XL (USA sizing) fits true to size, offering a relaxed but not overly baggy fit. Wool can sometimes feel scratchy, but this vest has a softer texture, likely due to its quality weave. The lack of a lining might be a drawback for some, but it allows for better breathability—ideal for active outdoor use.
Since fishing often involves a lot of arm movement, I tested the vest’s flexibility. The wool has enough stretch to allow free motion without feeling restrictive. The lightweight yet warm nature of the material makes it a great transitional piece for spring and fall fishing trips.
4. Price & Value for Money
The Kylebooker VTG Smith & Hawken vest is priced in the mid-range for wool hunting vests, typically retailing between $50 to $80 depending on the seller. Considering its durability, classic styling, and versatility, it offers solid value.
Compared to modern technical fishing vests (which can cost upwards of $100), this vest may lack specialized features like built-in rod holders or waterproof pockets. However, if you prioritize warmth, timeless style, and multi-purpose use, this is a great budget-friendly alternative.
5. Final Verdict: Is It Worth It?
For fishing enthusiasts who also enjoy hunting or general outdoor activities, this vest is a cost-effective, high-quality option. Its wool construction ensures longevity, and its classic design makes it a versatile addition to any outdoorsman’s wardrobe.
However, if you’re looking for a dedicated fishing vest with specialized storage, you might want to consider a more technical option. But for those who appreciate vintage aesthetics, durability, and multi-functional use, the Kylebooker VTG Smith & Hawken vest is an excellent buy.
Rating: 8.5/10
– Pros: Durable wool, classic style, good warmth, reasonable price
– Cons: Limited fishing-specific features, may require layering in extreme cold
Would I recommend it? Yes—especially for anglers who enjoy a rustic, functional look without breaking the bank.